The Pros and Cons of Buying New Construction v.s. Resale Homes

The Pros and Cons of Buying New Construction v.s. Resale Homes

In the quest for the perfect home, buyers often face a critical decision: Should they invest in a newly constructed house with all the modern trimmings or opt for the character and history of a resale home

This blog explores the unique advantages and challenges of each option, providing a comprehensive comparison to help you navigate this important decision.

PROS of New Construction Homes

1. Customization Options

One of the most appealing aspects of new construction homes is the ability to customize. Buyers often have the opportunity to select from a range of finishes, from flooring and paint colors to countertops and cabinet styles. This customization extends to the home's layout and other architectural details, allowing for a personalized space that reflects individual tastes and needs. 

Whether it's choosing an open-plan kitchen or adding an extra bedroom, new-construction homes offer a level of personalization that resale homes typically cannot match.

2. Modern Amenities

New construction homes come equipped with the latest advancements in home technology and energy efficiency. These may include smart home systems that control lighting, heating, and security, high-efficiency appliances, and sustainable materials that reduce the home's carbon footprint. 

Additionally, new homes are often designed with current trends in mind, offering contemporary aesthetics and layouts that cater to modern lifestyles. Think of spacious master suites, large windows for natural light, and outdoor living spaces, all of which are common in new constructions.

3. Fewer Initial Repairs

A significant benefit of buying a new construction home is the reduced need for immediate repairs. Everything from the appliances to the roofing is brand new, which means they are less likely to require maintenance or replacement in the near future. This can offer peace of mind to homeowners, knowing that unexpected repair costs are less likely to arise shortly after purchase. 

The reliability of new installations and the use of modern building materials also contribute to a sense of security and comfort that comes with new construction homes.

4. Builder's Warranty

New construction homes usually come with a builder's warranty. These warranties can cover a range of components and workmanship issues for varying lengths of time. For example, a typical warranty might offer one year of coverage for labor and materials, two years for mechanical defects (plumbing, electrical, heating, and air conditioning), and up to ten years for structural issues. 

This warranty acts as a safety net, providing buyers with protection against potential construction defects and the assurance that any issues that arise within the warranty period will be addressed by the builder. This is a level of security that resale homes, especially older ones, cannot provide.

CONS of New Construction Homes

1. Longer Wait Times

One of the primary drawbacks of new construction homes is the potential for longer wait times. Unlike purchasing a resale home that is ready for immediate move-in, new constructions require time for building and finishing. 

Delays can be common due to various factors such as weather, supply chain issues, or labor shortages. This means buyers might have to wait several months to a year or more before they can move into their new home. This waiting period can be challenging for those who have tight timelines or are in transition.

2. Higher Initial Costs

New construction homes often come with a higher price tag compared to resale homes. The costs of new materials, modern amenities, and the premium for customization contribute to this. Additionally, buyers might find themselves paying extra for upgrades or additions that go beyond the standard offerings. 

This can quickly escalate the overall cost, making new construction a more expensive option upfront. It's important for buyers to budget carefully and consider these additional expenses when deciding to opt for a new construction.

3. Less Room for Negotiation

The pricing model for new construction homes often leaves less room for negotiation. Builders typically have set prices for their homes and are less likely to move on these prices compared to individual sellers of resale homes. 

While there might be some flexibility in negotiating upgrades or closing costs, the base price of the home is usually non-negotiable. This fixed pricing model can be a disadvantage for buyers who are used to the bargaining process and looking to get the best possible deal.

4. Potential for Nearby Construction

Purchasing a new construction home in a developing neighborhood means there is a potential for ongoing construction nearby. This can result in noise, dust, and general disruption for a prolonged period. The landscape of the neighborhood can continuously change as new homes are built, which might affect the initial appeal of the area. 

Moreover, amenities like parks, schools, and shopping centers might still be in development, impacting the immediate livability and convenience for residents. Buyers should consider these factors and the potential impact on their daily life and long-term satisfaction with the area.

PROS of Resale Homes

1. Established Neighborhoods

One of the most significant advantages of purchasing a resale home is the opportunity to live in an established neighborhood. These areas often feature mature landscaping, developed infrastructure, and a sense of community that has been built over time. 

Established neighborhoods typically have well-defined amenities like parks, schools, and shopping centers, all contributing to a higher quality of life. The presence of long-term residents can also foster a strong community spirit, offering new homeowners a sense of belonging and security.

2. Room for Negotiation

Resale homes generally offer more room for negotiation on price. Unlike new constructions, where prices are often fixed by the builder, resale home prices can be more flexible. This allows buyers to negotiate based on factors like the age of the home, the need for renovations, or market conditions. 

The ability to negotiate can result in a final purchase price that is more aligned with the buyer's budget and perceived value of the home, potentially leading to significant savings.

3. Unique Charm and Character

Resale homes often come with unique charm and character that new constructions may lack. These homes can feature distinctive architectural details, like original hardwood floors, crown moldings, or vintage tiles that reflect the period in which they were built. 

There's also an aspect of history and a story behind older homes that many buyers find appealing. This character, combined with modern updates, can create a unique and inviting living space that stands out from the uniformity of new constructions.

4. Quicker Move-In Process

The process of buying and moving into a resale home can be much quicker than with new construction. Since the home is already built, buyers can skip the lengthy construction phase and move in soon after closing the deal. 

This is particularly advantageous for buyers on a tight schedule, such as those relocating for work or wanting to settle quickly for family reasons. The quicker move-in process can reduce the stress and uncertainty associated with waiting for a home to be built, making resale homes a practical option for many.

CONS of Resale Homes

1. Potential Hidden Costs

A significant drawback of purchasing resale homes is the potential for hidden costs due to unforeseen repairs and maintenance issues. Older homes may have underlying problems not immediately apparent during the initial inspection, such as plumbing issues, electrical problems, or structural concerns. 

These unexpected repairs can be costly and time-consuming, impacting the overall affordability and convenience of purchasing a resale home. Buyers should be prepared for the possibility of additional expenses that may arise after moving in.

2. Outdated Features

Resale homes, particularly those that haven't been updated in a while, often come with outdated features that may require modernization to meet current standards and tastes. This can include older appliances, dated bathroom and kitchen designs, and less functional layouts compared to newer homes. 

Renovating and updating these features to contemporary standards can be a significant investment, both financially and in terms of time. Buyers interested in resale homes should factor in the cost and effort needed for potential updates.

3. Energy Efficiency Concerns

Older homes may not be as energy-efficient as their newer counterparts. They often lack modern insulation, efficient heating and cooling systems, and energy-efficient windows, leading to higher utility bills and a larger carbon footprint. 

Making an older home more energy-efficient can involve substantial upgrades, such as installing new HVAC systems, adding insulation, or replacing windows, all of which can add to the overall cost of the home.

4. Limited Warranties

Unlike new construction homes, which often come with comprehensive builder's warranties, resale homes typically do not offer such extensive protection. While some appliances or systems may still be under the manufacturer's warranty, most elements of the home will not be covered. 

This means that buyers are generally responsible for any repairs or issues that arise, without the safety net of a builder's warranty to cover unexpected problems. This lack of warranty coverage is an important consideration for buyers, as it can significantly impact the long-term cost of maintaining the home.

The best decision depends on individual preferences, priorities, and circumstances. Whether it's the appeal of a modern, tailor-made home or the charm and immediacy of a resale property, each choice offers its unique benefits and challenges.

For those seeking further guidance or information, don't hesitate to reach out to real estate professional Joseph Sabeh. He can offer expert advice tailored to your specific needs and help you make an informed decision that best suits your lifestyle.







Aerial view of mansion

full service real estate team

Work With Us

Our team will support you and work together serving as a resource for you to achieve your goals. We will be there before, during, and after the close of escrow to provide assistance. Joseph Sabeh and the Joseph Sabeh Group exemplifies professionalism, integrity, and experience to best serve clients.

Follow Us on Instagram